Talk:Scarlet Fitch

"Dear Mr. Fitch, I was so disappointed that you missed our appointment last Thursday. This is the third time in a month that you've not appeared at the allotted time. I implore you to reschedule as soon as you can. We've made such progress over the past few months - I can't stress how important it is that we maintain regular contact to ensure a speedy recovery. I look forward to seeing you soon. Sincerely, Dr. Slater Chief Resident Psychiatric Department Alchemilla Hospital."

The letter to Fitch from Slater.

Judging from the context, the letter seems to concern only Dr. Fitch, and not Scarlet. There is no mention of her, or any indication of her presence in the Hospital at all.

Any thoughts? TheGoodman 16:26, 30 March 2009 (UTC)

From reading the note again and again, i can only say that it was for Dr. Fitch himself rather then Scarlet. It would also be odd why they institute such a young girl because she is a shut-in, wile it's more plausible that Dr. Fitch just lost his mind after he murdered his daughter. I'm going to edit the page.--SilentScream 18:12, 21 June 2009 (UTC)

Has anyone else noticed that in Scarlet's photograph she looks rather ghostly? It's possible to see the background through Scarlet, like she's transparent. Is it possible that this a photo that Josh took AFTER they had both died?

On another note, i'm fairly convinced that only Scarlet actually came back as a monster. After all, Dr. Fitch (though insane) seems to recognizes his daughter, and her boss form is the only monster that shares its respective child's name. In contrast, Mayor Bartlett implores God rather than his son to spare him from Sepulcher, and Judge Halloway is merely shocked after seeing Asphyxia. Also, if one looks carefully, Both Nora's AND Elle's pictures (even though Elle isn't dead) disappear from Elle's Locket when Asphyxia appears, lending evidence to the argument that Asphyxia is merely Halloway's tormentor representing her crimes and her family. In contrast, Dr. Fitch seems to believe that Scarlet has been communicating with him for some time in a ghost-like manner, whereas this didn't occur to Mayor Bartlett or Judge Halloway. - Webspidrman 01:28, 25 January 2011 (UTC)

I feel so bad for her...
(wraps barbed wire around the wiki Scarlet)

GOTCHA. Here's a muffin. *gives her a cranberry muffin*

Wait, could this be... the wrong person!?!?!??!?!?!?

Maybe I should have made a pomegranate muffin instead. What would those even taste like...? — Alex Shepherd   ツ  21:44, March 21, 2011 (UTC)

Hair and Eye color
I think her hair is more likely black than brown, and her eyes are possibly grey. First of all, the doll that bears a "striking resemblance to Scarlet" has black hair and grey eyes. Second of all, look at the pic if I sharpen it: (Creepy, huh?) — Jiya na miki  02:21, April 21, 2011 (UTC)


 * It's physically impossible for a human to have gray eyes, at least to my understanding. It is, however, possible for it to be shaded enough to have a gray hue, but no eyes are actually gray. I'll use my own eyes as an example: They're technically blue, but sometimes appear bluish-gray. Gray is merely a hue (defined as a shade or tint of a basic color), not the root coloration. ╟_Ωzz… &#12288; t a l k  16:56, January 1, 2014 (UTC)


 * This may apply in real life but it's possible that the writers of Homecoming did not know this. It's a beef I have with a lot of writers actually who describe their characters to have gray eyes (off the top of my head, in Memoirs of a Geisha which for the record is a poorly written, soft core porn novel disguised as a well-researched historical fiction on the lives of geisha, but okay, I'm getting off topic). Gray eyes are often just an exaggeration of hazel, or bluish gray like you said, but not brown. — LisaGarland ❤  05:32, January 2, 2014 (UTC)


 * In my honest opinion, I think we should just leave Scarlet's eye color as "Indeterminable" since she never really appears in the game, and basing her eye color off her doll or blurry photograph isn't enough. I also feel we should merge the Etymology section into her Trivia. — Alex Shepherd   ツ  06:07, January 2, 2014 (UTC)

Scarlet's letter
I have a sudden urge to replace the "Scarlet's letter" section with "The Scarlet letter" because that would be so inside. But it would also be stupid so I won't. — LisaGarland ❤  05:13, January 1, 2014 (UTC)