User talk:97.106.50.246

Maria
1. Mary tells James to end the suffering in "In Water" ending.

2. "FALSE, that's the REAL Mary. She is a GHOST"
 * This is a speculation. Or maybe that are the other words for manifestation. If that Mary, who James is talking to in Leave, In Water and Maria ending is a ghost, then Maria can also be called "a ghost". If you can prove, that this is the real Mary, then show me. And tell me, what are the differences between ghost and manifestation, because IMO they can be considered as the same type of being.

3. Why have you cancelled "(or maybe not, if he learned something from his experiences at Silent Hill.)"? Why are you crossing out the possibility, that he will continue care of Maria during the ilness? Player's actions leading to "Maria Ending" clearly show that James in this ending is protective, caring, reliable and has a willingness to sacrifice (vide "How to be a happy couple" memo).

If we consider James' doings during the game, Maria has a bigger chance to live happily with James in 'Maria Ending', than Laura in 'Leave Ending'

Because in "Leave" he didn't prove anything - he can still be considered as a selfish man (just remember how smoothly he rebuffed Maria, just because "he doesn't need her anymore"). BFAW stated that Maria is a feeling and thinking being. She suffered so much because of James' sins and she can truly hate him, if he doesn't care about her. In contrast, if he really shows cariness and acceptance, she can truly love him for this.

SH2 is ambiguous and endings are open. Don't forget, that Book of Lost Memories suggests, that Maria will fall ill, BUT NOT that James will kill her in desperation.

80.51.98.5 18:08, 22 March 2009 (UTC)