Butter Cake

Butter Cake is a frequently reappearing item in Silent Hill 2, Silent Hill 3 and Silent Hill 4: The Room. It has spurred a joke within the fandom, where players have tried to locate all the boxes they can.

Silent Hill 2



 * Blue Creek Apartments, Room 109, on the floor
 * Blue Creek Apartments, Room 307, in the cupboard
 * Heaven's Night, on a shelf
 * Toluca Prison
 * Lakeview Hotel, in the kitchen
 * Lakeview Hotel, in the pantry
 * Baldwin Mansion, on the counter in the service room

Silent Hill 3

 * Construction Site, on the floor
 * Hilltop Center, on a desk
 * Heather Mason's kitchen, on the counter
 * Heaven's Night, on a shelf
 * Lakeside Amusement Park, on a shelf in the Sweet Factory Store
 * Lakeside Amusement Park, inside the Magic Ice Cream House

Silent Hill 4: The Room



 * Bar Southfield, behind the bar
 * Room 301, on the counter
 * Room 203, on the shelf

Silent Hill: Book of Memories
It is also a DLC Artifact in Silent Hill: Book of Memories. The artifact can be purchased from Howard's Shop with a price tag of 6,400 MR.

Trivia

 * Gourmet Gaming created real-life Butter Cake.